| 2012 | Alex Cillo, David Duffett, Ryan Ebner |
| 2011 | Dylan Seeley, Doug Shribman |
| 2010 | Ben Allen, Andrew Brouse, B.J. La Rosa, Ben Yoder |
| 2009 | Dane Grandizio, Ben Yoder |
| 2008 | Mark Angelo, Jason Buursma, Mathew Wilson |
| 2007 | Matt Curry, Ryan Gryskevicz, Nathan Mittag |
| 2006 | Matt Capece, Brad Duvall, Kyle Walter |
| 2005 | Brian Day |
| 2004 | Sam Moss, Ben Stoll, Pete Wolf |
| 2003 | Zachary Allen, R.J. Grant |
| 2002 | Gregg Farmery, Eric Fishman |
| 2001 | Brad Gething, Chris Herron |
| 2000 | Frank Fresconi, Matt Potalivo, Tyler Prout |
| 1999 | Eric Junge, Mike McCarthy |
| 1998 | Mike Anders, Dave Apollon |
| 1997 | Pete Cann, Alex Inclan, Steve Rutkowski |
| 1996 | Chad DeHart, Heath Mathias, Kevin Silverman |
| 1995 | Kyle Morris, Dave Scranton |
| 1994 | John Martine, Scott Sutfin |
| 1993 | Michael Kearns, Larry Trout |
| 1992 | Mark Kennedy, Dave Koerner |
| 1991 | Roger Ahrens, Mark Kennedy, Ted Obligado |
| 1990 | Mike Dermer, Jeff Heuer, Joe Markulike |
| 1989 | Mike Dermer, Joe Markulike, Ed Snyder |
| 1988 | Arnie Mascali, Scott Rifkin, Ed Snyder |
| 1987 | John Hamilton, David Papp |
| 1986 | Jay Jeney, Scott Slifer |
| 1985 | Mike Bayles, Don Leitzel |
| 1984 | Brian Bastecki |
| 1983 | Paul Bamford |
| 1982 | Jim Cawley |
| 1981 | Bill Lawrence |
| 1980 | Bill Lawrence |
| 1979 | Bob Simonson |
| 1978 | Bill Schultz, Bob Simonson |
| 1977 | David Kasputis, John Recco |
| 1976 | Warren Bumpus, John Havas, Kraig Kummer |
| 1975 | Dennis Deihm |
| 1974 | Raymond Linstrum, William Walsh |
| 1973 | Stephen Eck |
| 1972 | Michael Marinchak |
| 1971 | Eugene Luccarelli |
| 1970 | Victor Cegles, Randall Ruger |
| 1969 | Frank Arentowicz |
| 1968 | Richard Frick |
| 1967 | |
| 1966 | Mike McAllister |
| 1965 | Bryan Kenny |
